|
|
Coordinators for Scientific and Strategic Issues (CSSI)
2002 report
A. Introduction
The CSSI group, established by the 6th Assembly of Partners
(Casablanca, 14 January 2002), could meet twice along 2002 :
- in Budapest (8, 9, 11 March 2002),
- in De Bilt, before the EWGLAM meeting (6 October 2002).
Most exchanges were by e-mail, because of the very few
opportunities to travel and meet.
Here is a report of its activities along 2002, following the
list of duties assigned by Directors. A few recommendations for improving the
efficiency of research actions are also expressed.
B. Activities
1. Define priorities of the scientific plan
An executive summary underlying the main challenges for the
three coming years was written.
Besides, a work plan for 2002 was designed at the beginning
of the year, as a guideline for researchers. The most important and (assumed)
reachable goals were identified, together with a list of persons or teams
likely to work on each topic (an item with none involved cannot progress ...)
and potential external collaborations.
2. Precise cooperation with HIRLAM, UKMO and COSMO
Whenever possible, potential collaborations at the European
level were mentioned in the work plan for 2002.
However the cooperation between European LAM NWP consortia is
already managed at the EWGLAM and SRNWP levels. To enhance or start
collaborations, a minimum participation of ALADIN partners to the already
organized workshops is required. Participation to scientific meetings
organized by other consortia has been recommended in the SRNWP framework for
several years.
Here is the list of such meetings in 2002 :
- - HIRLAM workshop on Variational Data Assimilation and Remote Sensing
- Helsinki, 21-23 January
- ALADIN participants : L. Berre, P. Caille, E. Gérard (Fr)
- - SRNWP workshop on System Collaboration
- Toulouse, 13-15 May
- ALADIN participants : R. El Khatib, J.D. Gril, E. Sevault (Fr), Z.
Sahlaoui (Mo), F. Vana (LACE)
- - COSMO annual meeting
- Warsaw, 25-27 September
- ALADIN participants : none
- - SRNWP workshop on LAM EPS
- Madrid, 03-04 October
- ALADIN participants : A. Horanyi (Hu), J. Nicolau (Fr), Y. Wang (Au)
- - EWGLAM / SRNWP annual workshop and special SRNWP workshop on August floods
- De Bilt, 07-10 October
- ALADIN participants : S. Alexandru, D. Banciu (Ro), F. Bouyssel, D.
Giard (Fr), R. Brozkova (Cz), L. Gérard (Be), T. Haiden (Au), A.
Horanyi (Hu), S. Ivatek-Sahdan (Hr), M. Monteiro (Pt), J. Vivoda (Sk)
- - HIRLAM workshop on Mesoscale Modelling
- Dublin, 14-16 October
- ALADIN participants : D. Klaric (Hr)
- - SRNWP workshop on Numerical Technics
- Toulouse, 12-13 December
- ALADIN participants : P. Bénard, J.F. Geleyn (Fr), R.
Brozkova ?, P. Smolikova ? (Cz), G. Radnoti ? (Hu), Y. Wang ? (Au), ?
Let us underline that the French participation to HIRLAM
meetings initiates from an old Météo-France <-> HIRLAM
cooperation, rather than from an ALADIN participation.
A few more specialized axes of cooperation were identified
along the last EWGLAM meeting : training, multi-model LAM EPS, reference
datasets for high resolution modelling, reference (quasi) academic experiments
for the evaluation of dynamics, ...
To end with, let us mention that the SRNWP network sent an
"Expression of Intererest" for a "network of excellence"
in the framework of the forthcoming 6th Framework Program for Research and
Development of the European Union. It is entitled : " Improvement
of Weather Forecasting and Risk Assessment in Europe by Very High Resolution
Simulations, Ensemble Forecasting and Modelling System Developments
". If the proposal is accepted, this could help
enhancing exchanges at the European level; however around 100 such demands
were submitted in the domain of environmental sciences.
3. Select coordinators, organise more efficient networking
A list of thematic coordinators was proposed by CSSI during
its first meeting. For domains where networking was already quite efficient,
such as numerics or data assimilation, the previous organization was kept.
Oppositely, for physics, many subtopics were considered, since research was
very centralized up to now and there are not so many experts. To end with,
some domains still miss a coordinator though not of minor importance
(operations, maintenance, verification, applications).
To start or help networking, several mini-workshops were
organized along the first semester of 2002, taking advantage of the
simultaneous presence of many scientists in Toulouse, Kranjska-Gora or
Medulin. Some were quite technical, for example those of dynamics. But for
most the first aim was to allow persons interested and likely to work in a
research topic to meet, know each other and discuss problems and proposals,
first. That is the minimum required for working together afterwards. This is
of course to be completed by training, intensive e-mail exchanges and thorough
distance supervision.
The research plan under its various versions (full,
presentation, summary), the work plan for 2002, the lists of coordinators,
most reports from working groups, ... are easily available on the ALADIN web
site, at the following address : http://www.cnrm.meteo.fr/aladin/scientific/.
4. Follow the progress of the AROME project
The CSSI group had no means, officially, to follow the
progress of the AROME project. The reports from meetings are available only
within Météo-France (internal web site, restricted e-mail list),
in French.
However the project leader very recently agreed to provide
informations, via the ALADIN Newsletters, on the research performed with
ALADIN in the AROME framework.
5. Report to the Assembly
Here is the written report, since a participation of
the CSSI group to the 7th Assembly of Partners, to report and discuss with
Directors, was clearly not scheduled (by none).
C. Recommendations
1. Introduction
First the five active members of CSSI would appreciate a
modification of the composition of the group, since the sixth member, A.
Mokssit, did not help at all, not even answering a mail. The committee could
be reduced to 5 persons, or kept to 6 scientists with an efficient replacement.
Second it is clear that an efficient decentralized
research cannot work without a minimum of means. They are listed hereafter.
2. Researchers
For already several years, some ALADIN teams often reach a
sub-critical size (even reaching 1 person !). A team of e.g. 3 persons in
charge of supervising the operational suite (including verification and
downstream adaptation), managing part of the computing department, developping
new tools for end-users, training newcomers, ... has only little time left for research.
3. Training
The decentralization of research relies on the (real)
availability of experienced researchers in each team, and the continouous
basic and advanced training of newcomers. A few years of work on ALADIN
as well as the participation to training courses or research stays abroad may
be necessary.
4. Meetings
Networking cannot succeed if people never meet. Every team
should send at least a participant to the ALADIN workshop, and as far as
possible also to the EWGLAM meeting, i.e. 1 or 2 travels per year.
5. Data exchange
Research on mesoscale data assimilation and verification is
likely to slow down very soon if high resolution (in space and time)
observational data cannot be exchanged between ALADIN partners at least (not
in real time first).
The problems related to the lack of documentation for ODB
(Observational Data Base, the new interface between model and observations
developped by IFS), hence/and its poor portability, are also to be underlined.
All the more since ODB must be used with the most recent versions of the
ALADIN library. Two complementary actions are to be considered : an official
demand from NMSs to ECMWF and exchanges of experience during the LACE training
course on maintenance organized in Budapest in November.
Both items also meet SRNWP recommendations (real-time
exchange of hourly SYNOP data, common interface to observation databases).
6. Maintenance
As usual !
D. List of joint pieces
- Executive summary of the third medium-term research plan
- Work plan for ALADIN : 2002
- List of coordinators
- List of coordination meetings (most reports are available
in the 22th ALADIN Newsletter)
- Progress in research along 2002 (reports from coordinators)
- SRNWP Expression of Interest
|